Millie's of Staten Island - Staten Island, New York

Andre Cirilo

OMG! Millie's of Staten Island gets 5 flames ?!

First, if you're a meat eater, you have to try the 42oz. Porterhouse steak for two. It was an absolute delight. Cooked to perfection, it was the star of the service. We paired our steak with sautéed spinach, some scalloped potatoes, and a salad.

Second, the house salad dressing, a blue cheese lover dream, is delicious and needs to be bottled!

Third, the coal and wood fired pizzas are perfect. One with a thin crust, the other with a thicker crust, but they both satisfy and stand out amongst most pizzerias on Staten Island.

Fourth, the marinara sauce is vibrant and fresh, which helps elevate any dish that it is served with.

There's more... the meatballs ?, the seafood ?, the drinks ?, all fresh and delicious. Z

Finally, the service... top of the line. Staff are welcoming, patient, and knowledgeable.

Do yourself a favor and plan a visit to Milkie's of Staten Island. You won't be disappointed!

Micah Mills

It was my first time with a group of seven people. This place was at the same area where I went to Applebee's.? I went inside and the place looked exquisitely fancy. The atmosphere felt very nice btw. ?They had this side Glass Wall lined up with different kinds of wine ?. There was a concession stand where we came in the entrance and from across the room, there was this coal like oven with fire lit up. ? We were there to do volunteer work for the place and stack some pizza boxes on top of each other(big and small). I told them I had experience of folding boxes because I used to work in a pizza place before. (Tony's Brick oven)So I did the most work while the others tried their best. After we were done folding boxes, we sat at a table until 12:00 so we can have their two medium Pizza pies for a job well done ? and I kid you not, it was delicious. ? ️ They're coal fired Pizza was baked and made differently. I did want to ask them if they had drinks ? because they had a bar in there with glass ? hanging around but I didn't want to push it even further. After we ate, the waiter told us"do you want to eat the rest of it here or to go"I said "to go"and they put it in individual boxes. ? I went to the bathroom and it looks clean as a whistle. With red and black paint too! Maybe I'll come back here again for The full experience. I might even want to work there too since I'm so good at folding boxes. ?

Dorothy Gordon

Came here for father's day,with the family. Having never been here,I was looking forward to this meal. It dud not disappoint. The T-bone steak was exceptional. Cooked to perfection. Mashed potatoes,creamed spinach delicious.
I particularly liked that the restaurant did not put up lots of extra tables,they were spaced so that there was no feeling of being crowded in.
The service was great.
Am looking forward to returning

Connie Mazella

Food and service were excellent. Wait staff and owner/manager were extremely attentive. We really enjoyed our meal and even though the place was packed, we were not rushed and enjoyed our company through a leisurely dessert. (We did have a reservation.)

The only thing that wasn't excellent were the bathrooms. They were unisex, big enough to accommodate a wheelchair or walker, fully stocked with soap, seat guards and TP, but the men who used them left the seats up were not "careful" when they used them so the floor was wet around the toilets. Perhaps they were short staffed that night, but when I went to the bathroom again at the end of the dinner, 3 out of the 4 bathrooms had the toilet seats up. You can't account for bad manners. Perhaps identifying separate men and women rooms would have helped, although as a woman who has waited on a line to use the bathroom, like the idea of unisex bathrooms.

I definitely recommend the restaurant and would go back. Hoping this was just a perfect storm of bad manners, unexpected staff absence and high percentage of men that evening.

Tommy T

The oysters were amazing. Can wait till go back next time to try the pizza and meatballs.
This is a perfect dinner place before or after watching a movie.

Edgardo Rios

Came here with my fiancee for the 1st time yesterday after finding them on Google and the food was absolutely mind blowing. The meatballs were the best I've ever had and it takes alot for me to say that! However the waitress was a little snippy serving us but that's ok. She was probably having a bad hair day. The atmosphere was very chilled. You can have some drinks and just grab a good bite! Will definitely be back!

Joe Bruno

1st time here and I believe it's been open for some time now... I can't believe I missed out on this all that time. The wait staff was very well attentive and the Manager is one if the nicest guys. I forgot to take food pics of dinner but I did get the oven Roasted Oysters which was really outta the park hit! he Cookies and Cream desert, and Tartufo was my Bonus!!

Robert Nelson

A group of us went on a Sunday, they were running a special $20 all you can eat. We definitely took them on their offer and arrived with an empty stomach.
Overall our group enjoyed the service and food.
Our server was great, checked on us numerous times, always made sure there was food & drinks in front of us.
If you look at the picture of the bill you can see what we had[we had a lot!!] I loved the oysters, meatballs, & eggplant sandwiches.
I will definitely check out this place again.