Pie Society - San Marcos, Texas

Anthony Conner

I recently visited Pie Society and had an exceptional experience. From the moment we walked in, the staff was incredibly friendly, making us feel welcome. The atmosphere was amazing, providing a comfortable and enjoyable dining environment.

Service was impressively fast, which we appreciated. The prices were decent, offering good value for the quality of food served. Speaking of the food, the pizza was both visually appealing and absolutely delicious. My daughter had a meatball sandwich, which she thoroughly enjoyed. The pizzas we ordered were equally fantastic.

Overall, Pie Society exceeded our expectations in every way. I highly recommend this place for anyone looking for great pizza and excellent customer service.

CJ Weinstein

The pies were outstanding. I have missed real Northeast Pizza but this takes its place. The standard peperoni is as greasy and delicious as it should be, and the Garden of Eden were crave able delights of perfectly cooked veggies with depth of flavor. Only complaint was that while we sat outside a few of the tables were not bused and there were birds all over the table next to us. When the picnic table was bused the table was never wiped clean. Inside had a cool vibe. Hang out at the bar, or at a long table in a group or grab a slice and enjoy the energy of everyone there.

Pedro Hernández Santiago

It was my first time at this place, and the experience was good; the bar tender was awesome, and the ambient was really friendly. If I pass back again in this area, for sure I will stop by. Beers ? and spirits are good, and don't forget the pizza.

David Herring

This pizza place is AMAZING. The flavors of the toppings are great. They have a lot of signature pizzas which are pretty classic but with a nice twist. The special that I had was super good and was a flavor that I never had on a pizza before. It was an al pastor flavor. One of the best pizzas that I've ever had and I would totally recommend eating here.

David Crow

Happy to say I finally found the best pizza in San Marcos. Sorry to say it took a few years. I’d love to see better beer selections on tap as quantity on hand. Some nice IPA’s from CO, OR would make this place an easy 5 for me. Only having Texas beer is sad.

david montoya

Rude counter help would liken it to the type of people that work in the most hipster of coffee shops. Made our pizza without sauce order it online 20 minutes before we got there pretty sure they didn't start the order until we asked about it. The only person working there that wasn't completely rude was the manager and he looked like he was trying to pick up the slack from everybody else. After they corrected our pizza we took it home still wasn't that good not worth the wait.

Paul Carter

While in San Marcos, you gotta visit Pie Society! Seriously such a great pizza spot. Wide selection of pies, starters, salads, and calzones. We went in for a couple slices and split the Greek salad and some garlic knots as well. Got The Pyramid (Garlic infused extra virgin olive oil, fresh spinach, ricotta, fresh mozzarella, Texas goat cheese) and the Balance of Power (Fresh spinach, spicy sausage, crushed red peppers & a touch of Texas honey) slices and wow they were both phenomenal! Everything we had was amazing. Great atmosphere, super friendly staff as well. Ordered a Live Oak Hefeweizen to wash it down because it's one of the best craft beers in Texas. Can't wait to go back and try more of their pies!

Reese Mc

This is a great meet up place! The plaza this place is in is pretty small which gets packed pretty fast so be aware. The place wasn’t crazy big and we arrived at 11:30 for lunch and I’m glad we did cause it started filling up. The staff was super friendly though, answered all the questions I had since it was my first time in. Basically when you enter you find your seat then head to the front bar to place your order. No waiters just staff in general delivering your food and beer if you ordered it. They also had soda, tea and water. I enjoyed their blueberry soda. We ordered a pepperoni slice, Balance of power pie, the pyramid pizza toppings and added fennel sausage made into a calzone and the 78-666 pizza toppings made into a calzone. My pyramid calzone was super delicious and big so leftovers for sure. Tons of cheese so chew chew chew so you don’t choke haha. Everyone in my party enjoyed their food and complimented on how good it was so we have zero complaints. Things to note only one stall restroom for men and women but was nice and clean. Would definitely go back for sure.